Sources of Nahj al Balaghah


The most important work of al-Radi is the compilation of selected
sermons, letters and sayings of Amir al-Mu'minin 'Ali (as). He selected
241 sermons, 79 letters, and 489 sayings. Those numbers vary in
different editions of Nahj al-balaghah. The number of sermons varies
from 238 to 241 and the number of letters varies from 77 to 79, whereas
sayings vary from 463 to 489. Al-Radi, in the introduction to Nahjal-
balaghah, gives an account of the circumstances that led him to compile
the utterances and writings of 'Ali (as). According to this account, while
busy in writing Khasa'is al-A'immah he planned to devote the last part
of the book to the sayings and writings of Amir al-Mu'minin (as). This
task was so absorbing and fascinating that his friends and brothers-in-faith
desired that he should compile a book covering all the forms of 'Ali's
utterances such as letters, lectures, counsels, moral admonitions and
aphorisms, for, they would prove to be masterpieces of eloquence,
rhetoric, aphorisms and jewels of wisdom, probably the best after the
Quran and hadith of the Prophet (as) in Arabic language and literature.
He writes:

        ... And these were not collected in any other work, nor 
        found together in any other book ... Amir al-Mu'minin (as) 
        was the fountain of eloquence and (his utterances) the 
        source of rhetoric. Through him hidden delicacies of 
        eloquence and rhetoric came to light, and from him were 
        learnt its principles and rules. Every speaker and orator 
        had to tread on his footprints, and every eloquent preacher 
        availed of his utterances. Even then they could not equal
        him, for the credit for being the first and foremost remained 
        with him, because his utterances were those that carried 
        the reflection of Divine knowledge and savour of the Prophet's 
        utterances. Accordingly I acceded to their request, as I knew 
        that it meant great reward, handsome reputation and a 
        treasure of recompense. The object of this compilation is 
        that I should bring forth Amir al-Mu'minin's greatness and 
        superiority in the art of rhetoric which is in addition to 
        his countless qualities and innumerable distinctions, and to 
        show that he has risen to the highest pinnacle of this 
        attainment, is singular among all those predecessors whose 
        utterances are quoted here and there, whereas his own utterances 
        are like an onrushing and irresistible stream, and such a 
        treasure of subtleties in language is unmatched. Since I proudly 
        trace my descent from him I feel pleasure in quoting a couplet 
        of al-Farazdaq:

                        These are my forefathers O Jarir
           When we get together, can you cite any as their equals?

        In my view Amir al-Mu'minin's utterances are divisible in 
        three categories: firstly sermons and decrees, secondly 
        letters and communications, and thirdly maxims and counsels. 
        Allah willing I intend to compile first the sermons, then
        letters, and then maxims and counsels, and propose a separate 
        chapter for each category, leaving blank pages in between 
        each of them so that if anything has been left out and is 
        found afterwards it may be inserted there in ...

Apart from al-Radi's assessment of 'Ali's utterances and their
literary as well as philosophical aspect, the important point to be noted
is his reference to other sources. This is in itself enough to counter
the allegations of the later writers like Ibn Khallikan and Ibn Hajar that
a major portion of Nahj al-balaghah was falsely ascribed to 'Ali (as).
Before coming to those allegations I would like to quote another passage
from al-Radi's introduction to Nahj al-balaghah which far more
explicitly refers to the earlier sources from which al-Radi selected the
contents of his compendium:

        In this compilation in some places there is repetition of 
        words or subject matter. The excuse for this is that Amir 
        al-Mu'minin's utterances have been related in numerous forms. 
        Sometimes it happened that a particular utterance was found 
        in a particular form in a tradition and was taken down in that 
        very form. Thereafter the same utterance was found in some 
        other tradition either with acceptable addition or in a better 
        style of expression. In such a case with a view to further 
        the object of compilation and to present a beautiful utterance 
        from being lost it was decided to repeat it. It has also happened
        that a particular utterance had appeared earlier but due to 
        remoteness it has been entered again. This is through omission, 
        not by intent. In spite of all this I do not claim that I have 
        collected Amir al-Mu'minin's utterances from everywhere and that 
        no single sentence of any type or construction has been left 
        out. In fact I do not rule out the possibility that whatever 
        has been left out might be more than what has been collected, 
        and what has been in my knowledge and use is far less than what 
        has remauned beyond my reach. My task was to strive to the best 
        of my capacity and it was Allah's part to make the way easy and 
        guide me to the goal; Allah may will so.

Sources of Nahj al Balaghah

Though al-Radi has not furnished a bibliography of the sources
from which he collected the writings and sayings of Amir al-Mu'minin (as)
he has referred occasionally to certain books and their compilers in
his explanatory notes on various sermons, letters and sayings. Several
scholars have sought to trace back the sources of different utterances
and letters collected in Nahj al-balaghah to the works compiled
centuries before the birth of al-Radi. The most painstaking research
in this context was done by an Indian Sunni scholar Imtiyaz 'Ali
'Arshi, who died a few years ago. He succeeded in tracing back the early
sources of 106 sermons, 37 letters and 79 stray sayings of Amir al-
Mu'minin (as) in his book Istinad-e Nahj al-balaghah, originally written
in Urdu, subsequently translated into Arabic in 1957, then into English
and Persian. The translator of the Persian text adds very useful notes,
which usually provide further knowledge about the sources of Nahj al-
balaghah and occasionally point out 'Arshi's errors in some matters.
However, this work still stands as the most valuable research in
this field. Besides this work, some others deserve special mention such
as 'Abd al-Zahra' al-Husayni al-Khatib's Masadir Nahj al-balaghah, Hibat
al-Din al-Shahristani's Ma huwa Nahj al-balaghah, Sayyid 'Ali al-Naqawi
al-Nasirabadi's introduction to the Urdu translation of Nahj al-balaghah
by Mufti Ja'far Husayn, and al-Mu'jam al-mufahras li alfaz Nahj al-
balaghah, a joint work of al-Sayyid Kazim al-Muhammadi and al-
Shaykh Muhammad Dashti. Sayyid Muhammad 'Askari Ja'fari and
Sayyid 'Ali Rida also dealt with the issue of basic sources of Nahj
al-balaghah in their prefaces to their separate translations of the book
into English. Here follows with some minor corrections and additions
'Arshi's list of the early sources containing the utterances and writings
of Ali (as)

1.  Khutab Amir al-Mu'minin 'ala al-manabir fi aljuma' wa al- 'a'yad
    wa ghayriha; by Zayd ibn Wahab al Jahni (d. 96/714-15). This book was
    available till the fifth century H, for Abu Ja'far al-Tusi (d. 460/1067)
    has quoted from it in his writings.

2.  Kitab khutab Amir al-Mu'minin, by Abu Ya'qub Isma'il ibn
    Mahran ibn Muhammad al-Sakuni al-Kufi (d. circa 148/765).

3.  Abu Mikhnaf Lut ibn Yahya al-'Azdi (d. circa 157/773-74) has
    quoted Amir al-Mu'minin's utterances in the following works of his
    own: Kitab al Jamal, Kitab ahl al-Nahrawan wa al-Khawarij, Kitab al-
    gharat, Kitab maqtal 'Ali, Kitab maqtal Muhammad ibn Abi Bakr wa al-
    'Ashtar wa Muhammad ibn Hudhaybah, and Kitab al-shurd wa maqtal
    'Uthman. (Here may be added another work: al-Khutbat al-Zahra'li
    Amir al-Mu'minin.)

4.  Kitab khutab Amir al-Mu'minin by Abu Muhammad Mas'adah
    ibn Sadaqah al-'Abdi al-Kufi (d. 183/799). He was a pupil of al' Imam
    Musa al-Kazim (as), and Ibn Shadhan has narrated traditions on his
    authority.

5.  Kitab khutab 'Ali by Abu Ishaq Ibrahim ibn al-Hakam ibn Zahir
    al-Fazari al-Kufi (d. 177/793) Abu al-'Abbas al-Najashi (d. 450/1058)
    has narrated on his authority.

6.  Abu Ishaq Ibrahim ibn Sulayman Hashami (Nahami) al-Khazzaz
    al-Kufi (third century H.) besides compiling al-Khutab li Amir al-
    Mu'minin, eompiled other books such as Kitab al-dua, Kitab khalq al-
    samawat, and Kitab maqtal Amir al-Mu'minin. Al-Shaykh al-Tusi has
    quoted from his works.

7.  Kitab khutab 'Ali Karram Allah wajhah by Abu Mundhir
    Hisham ibn Muhammad ibn Sa'ib al-Kalbi (d. 206/821). He also wrote
    Maqtal 'Uthman, Kitab al Jamal, Kitab Siffin, Kitab al-Nahrawan, al-
    Gharat and Maqtal Amir al-Mu'minin. His book containing al-Imam
    'Ali's khutab was studied by al-Najashi.

8.  Abu 'Abd Allah Muhammad ibn 'Umar al-Waqidi (d. 207/823)
    quoted al'Imam 'Ali's writings and sermons in many of his books such
    as Kitab al Jamal, Kitab Siffin and Kitab al-sunnah waal-jama'ah wa
    dhamm al-hawa wa tark al-Khawdrij fi al-fitan. Al-Radi has referred to
    some of his works. He also compiled Khutab Amir al-Mu'minin (as).

9.  Abu al-Fadl Nasr ibn Muzahim al-Manqari (d. 212/827)
    compiled a number of books, all of which contain utterances of 'Ali
    (as). Al-Najashi has mentioned these works: Kitab Siffin, Kitab al-
    Jamal, Kitab al-Nahrawan and al-Gharat. He also compiled Khutab 'Ali
    (as), Kitab al-manaqib, and Kitab akhbar al-Mukhtar.

10. Abu al-Khayr Salih ibn Abi Hammad al-Razi (214/829)
    compiled a book Khutab 'Ali (as). He was among the companions of al-
    Imam al-Hasan al-'Askari (as), and his book is mentioned in al-Najashi's
    al-Fihrist.

11. Abu al-Hasan 'Ali ibn Muhammad al-Mada'ini (d. 224/839)
    compiled Khutab 'Ali (as) wa kutubuh ila 'ummalih and some other
    books including Ta'rikh al-khulafa.

12. Abu al-Qasim al-Sayyid 'Abd al-'Azim ibn 'Abd Allah ibn 'Ali
    al-Hasani (d. 250/864), popularly known as Shah 'Abd al-'Azim, whose
    tomb at Shahr Ray is a place of pilgrimage. He also compiled Kitab
    Khutab 'Ali (as).

13. Abu Ishaq Ibrahim ibn Muhammad ibn Sa'id al-Thaqafi al-Kafi
    (d. 283/896) compiled different collections of al'Imam 'Ali's utterances
    and letters, which are: Rasa'il 'Ali, Kalam 'Ali fial-shura, al-Khutab 
    almu'arrabat, Kitab al-Saqifah, Maqtal 'Uthman, Kitab bay'at Amir al-
    Mu'minin, Kitab al-hakamayn, Kitab al-Nahrawan, and Kitab maqtal
    Amir al-Mu'minin. Al-Shaykh al-Tusi says that he came to know of all
    these books through Ahmad ibn 'Abdun.

14. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn Jarir ibn Rustam al-Tabari, one of
    the contemporaries of the famous historian Ibn Jarir al-Tabari (circa
    226-310/840-41-922), collected the sermons and letters of Amir
    al-Mu'minin in two of his books: al-Ruwat 'an Ahl al-Bayt and Kitab
    al-mustarshid.

15. Abu Ja'far Muhammad ibn Ya'qub al-Kulayni (d. 328/939)
    quoted a number of al-Imam 'Ali's sermons and utterances in Usul al-
    Kafi, Rawa'at al-Kafi and Rasa'il al-'Aimmah.

16. Abu Ahmad 'Abd al-'Aziz ibn Yahya ibn Ahmad ibn 'Isa
    al Jalludi (d. 320/932), besides Kitab al Jamal, Kitab Siffin, Kitab
    al-hakamayn, Kitab al-gharat, Kitab al-Khawdrij and Kitab hurub 'Ali,
    compiled ten volumes containing al-Imam 'Ali's writings and utter-
    ances: Khutab 'Ali, Kitab shi'r 'Ali, Rasa'il 'Ali Mawd'iz 'Ali, Dhikr
    kalaam 'Ali fi al-malahim, Qawl 'Ali fi al-shura, Kitab ma kana bayna 
    'Ali wa 'Uthman min ai-kalam, Kitab qadd' Ali, Kitab al-du'a 'an 'Ali,
    Kitabal-'adab 'an 'Ali.

    Hibat al-Din al-Shahristani has mentioned the following other
    books: Kitab dhikr 'Ali li Khadijah wa fada'il Ahl al-Bayt 'Alayhim 
    al salam.

17. Abu al-Hasan 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn 'Ali al-Mas'udi (d. 346/
    957), the author of the famous book Muruj al-dhahab, has collected
    numerous sermons and sayings of al-'Imam 'Ali (as) in Hada'iq al-
    'adhhan fi akhbar Al Muhammad and Mazahir al-'akhbar wa zara'if al-
    'athar.

18. Abu Talib 'Ubayd Allah ibn Abi Zayd Ahmad ibn Ya'qub ibn
    Nasr al-'Anbari (d. 356/967), author of one hundred and forty books,
    compiled a collection of supplications of the Imams (as) Ad'iyat al-
    'A'immah, in which supplications of Amir al-Mu'minin (as) are also
    included.

19. Abu 'Abd Allah Ahmad ibn Ibrahim ibn Abi Rafi' al-Kufi al-
    Baghdidi, a teacher of al-Shaykh al-Mufid (d. 413/1022) has collected
    the utterances of al-'Imam 'Ali (as) in his books al Kash fi ma
    yata'allaq bi al-Saqifah and al-Diya' (al-Safa') of tarikh al-'Aimmah.
    Al-Shaykh al-Tusi says he was introduced to his works through al-
    Mufid, al-Husayn ibn 'Ubayd Allah, Ahmad ibn 'Abdun and others.

20. Abu al-Abbas Ya'qub ibn Ahmad al-Saymari, probably son of
    Abu 'Abd Allah Ahmad ibn Ibrahim ibn Abi Rafi', mentioned above,
    compiled a collection of al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances and sermons.

21. Abu Sa'id Mansur ibn al-Husayn Wazir al-Abi (d. 422/1031)
    collected aphorisms by al-'Imam 'Ali (as) in Nuzhat al-'adab fi al-
    muhadarat, and subsequently brought out and abridged this book
    under the title Nathr al-durar.

Existence of sources prior to al Radi

A number of other works were also compiled before al-Radi that
contained al-'Imam 'Ali's writings and utterances. A selected list of
those may be added to the above-mentioned books: 

1.  Abu 'Uthman 'Amr ibn Bahr al Jahiz (d. 255/869) compiled in
    a book, Mi'at mukhtarah min kalam Amir al-Mu'minin, one hundred
    aphorisms selected from the utterances of 'Ali (as). His major work
    al-Bayan wa al-tabyin also contains the words of Amir al-Mu'minin
    (as).

2.  Ibrahim ibn Hilal al-Thaqafi (d. 283/896) edited a book entitled
    Rasa'il Amir al-Mu 'minin wa akhburuh wa hurubuh.

3.  Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Khalid al-Barqi (d. 270/883 or
    280/893), in his famous work al-Mahasin, considered to be the fifth
    Shi'i compendium of hadith after the Four Major Compendia (al-
    Kutub al-'arba'ah), has quoted al'Imam 'Ali's writings and sermons.
    He was a companion of al' Imam Muhammad al-Taqi al Jawad (as) and
    al' Imam 'Ali al-Naqi al-Hadi (as). Al-Shaykh al Saduq benefited from his
    works to a great extent.

4.  Abu Muhammad al-Hasan ibn 'Ali ibn al-Husayn ibn Shuibah
    al-Harrani al-Halabi (d. 320/932 or 380/990) collected some sayings
    and speeches of the Imam (as) in Tuhaf al-'uqul. He writes:

        If we desire to quote all his ('Ali's) sermons and utterances 
        only in regard to the Unity of God, leaving all other themes, 
        it would equal this very book.

5.  Al-Qadi Nu'man al-Misri (d. 363/973) compiled a book Khutab
    Amir al-Mu 'minin.

6.  Abu 'Abd Allah Muhammad ibn Muslim al-Kufi al-Maruzi al-
    Dinawari known as Ibn Qutaybah (213-276/828-889) in 'Uyun al-
    'akhbar and Ghara'ib al-hadith quoted utterances of al-Imam 'Ali (as).

7.  Ahmad ibn Wadih al-Ya'qubi (d. 276/889) quoted al-Imam Ali's 
    utterances in his well-known history Ta'rikh al-Ya'qubi.

8.  Abu al-'Abbas al-Mubarrad (d. 285/898) in his al-Fadil and
    al-Kamil.

9.  Tarikh al-rusul wa al-muluk by Muhammad ibn Jarir al-Tabari
    (d. 310/922).

10. Al-Hasan ibn 'Abd Allah ibn Sa'id al-'Askari (d. 382j992)
    narrated from al-'Imam 'Ali (as) some of his sermons in al-Mawa'id wa
    al-zawajir.

11. Abu Bakr Muhammad ibn Durayd al-'Azdi (d. 321/933)
    quoted some utterances of al-'Imam 'Ali (as) for furnishing examples
    of Arabic idioms, proverbs, and aphorisms in his major lexicon al-
    Jamharah fi al-lughah.

12. Al-'Iqd al-farid by Ibn 'Abd Rabbih (246-328/860-940).

13. Kitab al-'aghani and Maqatil al-Talibiyyin by Abu al-Faraj al-
    Isfahani (284-356/897-967).

14. Kitab al-nawadir by Abu 'Ali al-Qari' (d. 356/967).

15. Ibn Babawayh al Shaykh al Saduq (d. 381/991) quoted extensively 
    from al-'Imam 'Ali's utterances in Man la yahduruhu al-faqih, 
    I'lal al-sharayi', 'Uyun akhbar al-Rida, al-'Amali, Ma'ani al-
    'akhbar, al-Tawhid, al-Khisal, al-I'tiqad, Thawab al-'a'mal and other
    books.

16. Al Shaykh al-Mufid (d. 413/1022) quoted al-'Imam 'Ali's
    writings and sayings in many of his books, particularly devoting a
    lengthy section of al-'Irshad to Amir al-Mu'minin's sermons, judicial
    judgements, decrees, letters, and sayings. Among the extant works of 
    that period al-'Irshad is the most systematic and comprehensive record 
    of al-'Imam 'Ali's words after Nahjal-balaghah.

Other contemporary Scholars engaged in the collection

Among the contemporaries of al-Radi, several other scholars were engaged in 
collecting and quoting Amir al-Mu'minin's utterances in their works. The 
following can be named here: Ibn Miskawayh (d 421/1030) in Tajarib al-'umam, 
Hafiz Abu Na'im al-Isfahani (d. 430; 1038) in Hilyat al-'awliya', Shaykh 
ai-Ta'ifah al-Tusi (d. 460/1067) in al-Tahdhib, al-'Istibsar, al-'Amali 
and otherworks. Al-Qadi Abu 'Abd Allah Mukammad ibn Salamah al-Shafi'i 
(d. 453/1061) in Ma'alim al-hikam.

'Aziz Allah 'Utaridi has prepared a list of sources which includes many a 
name not found in other lists. Such names are as follows:

1.  Harith al-'A'war al-Hamdani: He compiled a collection of Imam 'Ali's 
    khutab before Zayd ibn Wahab. Al-Kulayni through Abu Ishaq al-Sabi'i 
    has quoted him as narrating the sayings of the Imam (as).

2.  Asbagh ibn Nubatah.

3.  'Ubayd Allah ibn Hurr al Ju'fi: The famous Sunni muhaddith al-Bukhari 
    has mentioned a collection of al' Imam 'Ali's words compiled by him. 
    He was a poet and an admirer of al-'Imam 'Ali (as), who never submitted 
    to Mu'awiyah and was involved in anti-State activities. Al-Imam al- 
    Husayn sought his help, but he declined to come to his side. Afterwards 
    he repented his failure to help him. Al-Najashi has referred to him in 
    his al-Rijal.

4.  Husayn ibn 'Abd Allah ibn Ibrahim al-Ghada'iri (d. 411/1020).

5.  Sa'sa'ah ibn Sawhan, a companion of al-'Imam 'Ali (as), who narrated the 
    Imam's instructions to Malik al-'Ashtar at the time of his appointment 
    to governership of Egypt.

6.  Faraj ibn Farwah compiled a collection of the Imam's sayings on the 
    authority of Mas'adah ibn Sadaqah, who narrated from al-'Imam Ja'far al 
    Sadiq (as). Al Sayyid 'Ali ibn Tawus wrote at the back of a manuscript 
    of this compilation that it was written after 200/815. This manuscript 
    was in possession of Hasan ibn Sulayman al-Hilli, from which he has 
    quoted in his works.

7.  Muhammad ibn al-Hasan al-Saffar al-'Ash'ari al-Qummi, author of Basa'ir 
    al-darajat, had compiled al-'Irshad containing the utterances of al-
    'Imam 'Ali (as); not available now.

8.  Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Muhammad Abu 'Ubayd al-Harawi (d. 401/1010) 
    compiled a book of the uncommon words used in the Quran and hadith, 
    in which he quoted from Amir al-Mu'minin also.

9.  Abu 'Ubayd al-Qasim ibn Salam al-Harawi also wrote a book on the 
    vocabulary of hadith, in which he referred to the utterances of the Imam 
    'Ali (as). Al-Sayyid al-Radi has referred to this work.

10. Ahmad ibn Yahya Tha'lab (d. 291/903), the grammarian.

11. Abu al-Qasim 'Abd Allah ibn Ahmad al-Ka'bi al-Balkhi (d. 319/931) has 
    quoted al-Khutbat al-Shiqshiqiyyah in his book al- 'Insaf.

12. Abu Ja'far ibn 'Abd al-Rahman ibn Qubbah al-Razi has quoted al-Khutbat 
    al-Shiqshiqiyyah on the authority of Abu Ja'far ibn Battah in 
    al- 'Insaf.

13. Ibrahim ibn Muhammad al-Bayhaqi (d. 225/839) has quoted extensively 
    from al-'Imam 'Ali (as) in al-Mahdsin wa al-masawi'.

14. Muhammad ibn Tayyib Abu Bakr al-Bahri al-Baqillani (d. 403/1012) has 
    quoted from al-lmam 'Ali (as) in I'jaz al-Qur'an.

15. Muhammad ibn Habib al-Hashimi al-Baghdadi (d. 245/859).

16. Muhammad ibn 'Abd Allah Hakim al-Nishaburi.

17. Ali ibn Muhammad ibn al-'Abbas al-Shirazi, popularly known as Abu 
    Hayyan al-Tawhidi, an eminent scholar, quoted from al-'Imam 'Ali (as) 
    in al-Basa'ir.

18. Abu 'Abd Allah al Marzabani al-Khurasani, a scholar of literature and 
    literary sciences, was one of the teachers of al-Mufid. His work al-
    Muwaffaq contains the utterances of al-Imam 'Ali (as).

19. Ahmad ibn 'Abd al-'Aziz al Jawhari; Ibn Abi al-Hadid quoted from him 
    in Sharh Nahj al-balaghah, particularly from his valuable book al-
    Saqifah.

20. Abu Ja'far al-Baladhuri (d. 279/892), author of Ansab al-'ashraf and 
   Futah al-bulddn, has quoted the words of al-lmam 'Ali (as) in his works.

21. Sulaym ibn Qays al-Hilali was among the first to compile a collection 
    of hadith, in which he quoted numerous traditions from al-Imam 
    'Ali (as).

22. Abu Hanifah al-Dinawari (d. 290/903), a very authentic narrator and an 
    authority in literary sciences, quoted a number of sermons and sayings 
    of al-Imam 'Ali (as) in al-'Akhbar al-tiwal.

23. Abd al-Rahman ibn Ishaq Abu al Qasim al-Zujaji (d. 339/950), the author 
    of al Jamal, in his other work, al-Amali, narrated the utterances of 
    al-Imam 'Ali (as).

24. Abd al-Malik ibn Muhammad al-Tha'alibi (350-429/961-1037), author of 
    Yatimat al-dahr in al-Ijaz wa al-'Ijaz, quoted many an utterance of 
    al-Imam 'Ali (as).

25. Abu 'Umar ibn Yusuf ibn Ya'qub al-Kindi (d. 350/961) in his book al-
    Wulat has narrated the words of al-lmam 'Ali (as).

26. Abu Talib 'Ubayd ibn Ahmad ibn Ya'qub al-'Anbari has narrated some 
    supplications of al-'Imam 'Ali (as) in his Kitab al-'ad'iyah.

27. Abu 'Abd Allah Ahmad ibn Ibrahim ibn Abi Rafi' authored two books, 
    one entitled Kashf dar akhbar wa ta'rikh Saqifat Bani Sa'idah and 
    Ta'rikh al-Aimmah, in which he quoted the utterances of al 'Imam 
    'Ali (as).

28. Abu Muhammad Ahmad ibn A'tham al-Kufi (d. 314/926-27)
    in Kitab al-futuh narrated the sermons and words of al-Imam 'Ali (as).

29. Abu Muhammad Husayn ibn Sa'id ibn Hammad ibn Mahran al-
    'Ahwazi collected some of the sermons and sayings of al-lmam 'Ali (as).

30. Ali ibn al-Wasiti, the author of 'Uyun al-hikam, compiled a
    book on Fadail Ahl al-Bayt in 457/1065, from which al-'Allamah
    Baqir al-Majlisi has quoted in the seventeenth volume of Bihar
    al-anwar. This book contains the utterances of al-Imam 'Ali (as).

31. Muhammad ibn Ahmad al-Washsha', author of a twenty-
    volume work Zuhrat al-Riyad, in his other work Zarf wa zurafa, has
    quoted from al-lmam 'Ali (as).

32. Abu al-Hasan 'Ali ibn Ibrahim ibn Hashim al-Qummi, one of
    the earliest Shi'i exegetes of the Quran, has quoted extensively from 
    al-Imam 'Ali (as).

33. Yazid ibn 'Abd al-Malik ibn al-Mughirah ibn Nawfal ibn Harth
    ibn 'Abd al-Muttalib (d. 167/783) is one of the authorities among
    narrators of hadith. He narrated in his works the sermons of al-'Imam
    'Ali (as). In one of his works entitled Tuhfat al-'ahbab wa ma'rifat
    imamat sayyid uli al-'albab, he has copied in full a sermon of al-
    Imam 'Ali (as) that was delivered on the occasion of the assassination
    of the Third Caliph and al-'Imam 'Ali's taking reigns of the caliphate 
    into his hands. This risalah is included in a collection of rasa'il 
    owned by Imam Yahya of Yaman. At the present it is in the British 
    Museum Library, London.

For many centuries, Shi'i, Sunni, Mu'tazili and other scholars
continued their pursuit to trace and collect the sayings and writings of
al-Imam 'Ali (as). The early sources from which al-Radi selected the
contents of Nahj al-baldghah seem to be inexhaustible. Recently some
letters of al-Imam 'Ali (as) were edited and translated into Urdu by a
Sunni scholar 'Abd al Salam of Rampur. All these letters were
addressed to different Companions of the Prophet (as), and were
published with replies by their addressees. However, Nahj al-balaghah
remains among all such collections, compiled before and after al-Radi,
the most outstanding of all due to its philosophical depth, literary
excellence, and the penetrating historical insight reflected in its
contents. The book has always been a source of enjoyment and
inspiration for scholars and thinkers of successive generations irrespec-
tive of their faith and creed.